Article Bites #35: The Negative association between Number of airway attempts and neuro-intact survival following OHCA

Article Summary by Casey Patrick, @cpatrick_89

Article: Murphy, D. L., Bulger, N. E., Harrington, B. M., Skerchak, J. A., Counts, C. R., Latimer, A. J., … & Sayre, M. R. (2021). Fewer tracheal intubation attempts are associated with improved neurologically intact survival following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Resuscitation, 167, 289-296.

Who, What, When, Where and How?

  • Who? – 1205 non-trauma OHCA patients with a endotracheal intubation attempt, defined as “the introduction of a laryngoscope past the teeth and concluded when the laryngoscope was removed from the mouth, regardless of whether or not an endotracheal tube was inserted.”

  • What? – Retrospective, observational, cohort (cohort = OHCA/intubation)

  • When? – Jan 2015 – June 2019

  • Where? – Seattle Fire

  • How? – Primary outcome = neuro intact survival (CPC1/2)

  • Excluded No attempt, BLS only, intubated after ROSC, DNR, other services

The Results

  • Age = 60’s/68% male/33% witnessed/61% received bystander CPR/ 21%  shockable rhythm

  • ROSC 44%/Hospital admission 38%/Survival to d/c 11%

  • First attempt success 65%/2nd 86%

  • Overall rate of supraglottic use – 2.8%/0.7% after 2 attempts/11.2% after 3 attempts/28.4% after 4+ attempts

  • Primary outcome = CPC 1/2

    • There was a negative correlation between # of ET attempts and neurologically intact outcome: 11% CPC 1/2 with ONE intubation attempt/4% with TWO/3% with THREE and 2% with FOUR+ (see Figure)

    • These differences held for shockable vs. non-shockable rhythms

    • Multivariable stats modeling adjusted for: age/sex/witness/bystander/times/initial rhythm

The Questions

  • What about SGA’s? – This isn’t a rehash of PART/AIRWAYS-2.  Overall rate of SGA use was very low.

  • Mean time to airway = 5min in this study

  • Yes, this is retrospective but… Very granular (especially in OHCA world)

  • Incorporated monitor data PLUS audio (1200 patients!!)

What Should We Do Now?

  • No, this doesn’t translate directly to agencies using “primary SGA” in OHCA

  • BUT…More evidence airway delays = worsened patient-oriented outcome

    • Should there be a more rapid transition to SGA use after failed primary intubation attempt?

  • BOTTOM LINE – Concentrate on the interventions that we KNOW matter: Early recognition and bystander CPR, access to early defibrillation, minimize pauses, proper compression rate and depth.

Edited & Accompanying Figure by EMS MEd Editor Maia Dorsett, MD PhD FAEMS (@maiadorsett)


More Posts

Commercial Tourniquet Use in Pediatrics

Article by Veronica “Vee” Smith, MD Case It’s 11 o’clock in the morning on a sunny autumn day. Your radio alerts you about a mass casualty event and you are then dispatched to what turns out to be a school shooting. The estimated casualty count is over 20 with an unknown number of injured victims


EMS Perspectives: An OpEd Page on the History and Future of EMS By Clayton Kazan, MD, MS, FACEP, FAEMS So we are about 54 years into the pilot project that is EMS and paramedicine.  That we would even exist, much less thrive, years later, was viewed by many as highly improbable at the time.  The

About the Author

Scroll to Top